#16 — Fred Minnick Top 100 American Whiskeys of 2025
The Compromise by NBC & Nashtucky · 122.60 Proof · $109.99
Nashville Barrel Company releases between 15 and 30 bottles per year across multiple series. Each is a cask-strength, non-chill filtered single barrel or carefully constructed blend. No proofing water. No mass production. No padding the catalog. The ranking below is based on critical recognition, flavor complexity, value at price, and overall significance in the NBC story.
#1
The Compromise — NBC & Nashtucky
The only easy choice on this list. #16 on Fred Minnick's Top 100 American Whiskeys of 2025 — and it's not a surprise once you taste it. The Compromise blends NBC's 9yr Kelvin MGP bourbon (60% corn, 36% rye) with Nashtucky's 7yr Kentucky straight rye in equal parts at cask strength. The result is something neither component could achieve alone: bourbon's caramel richness, rye's peppery structure, Kelvin's toasted oak, and a finish that runs long and dry. At $109.99 it's the most accessible entry point in the NBC portfolio and the most critically recognized release they've ever made.
✓ Verdict: The best starting point for anyone new to NBC. Also the best cocktail base in the portfolio — Manhattan, Vieux Carré, or neat with a few drops of water.
Shop The Compromise →
#2
NBC Vault Series — 21yr Tennessee Bourbon
Twenty-one years in ISC cooperage in Tennessee. These barrels were distilled when most NBC customers were in middle school. The Vault Series is among the oldest Tennessee whiskey available for purchase anywhere. The 84% corn mashbill produces a sweeter, softer base than Kentucky high-rye recipes — but 21 years of Tennessee summers transforms that into dark fruit, leather, toffee, and a tannic oak grip that makes the whiskey feel architectural. Three barrels are currently in stock: #1471 (119.98°), #1470 (122.26°), and #1480 (135.48°). If you've never had Tennessee bourbon at this age, it's a genuinely different category.
✓ Verdict: Best NBC release for serious collectors and age statement chasers. The rarest thing in the portfolio that you can still actually buy.
Shop Vault Series →
#3
NBC Founders Fourteen — 8yr MGP Kelvin
The bottles that made NBC who they are. 14 barrels of 8yr MGP Indiana bourbon aged in Kelvin cooperage — purchased before NBC had a name, before it had a tasting room, before it had anything except conviction that these barrels were worth holding. Six barrels are still available: #9, #10, #11, #12, #13, #14. #13 has 2 bottles remaining. When these are gone, they're permanently gone. The Kelvin cooperage distinguishes these from standard MGP releases — more toasted vanilla, heavier caramel, a slightly smoky finish. The 75/21/4 mashbill gives them more rye spice than you'd expect at this price.
✓ Verdict: Best NBC release for historical significance and narrative value. Barrel #11 (91 bottles remaining) is the safest pick for someone who wants a Founders barrel without urgency.
Shop Founders Fourteen →
#4
NBC Grateful Kelvin 10yr — #2061 or #2063
The 10yr Grateful Kelvin releases (#2061 and #2063) represent the Grateful Kelvin series at its best — two extra years of aging smooth out the rye's sharper edges while preserving the series' defining character: heavy caramel, chocolate, cocoa, roasted nuts, and the baking spice that 36% rye produces. The Kelvin cooperage adds a dark fruit and toasted oak dimension that standard MGP releases don't have. At $149.99 for a 10yr high-rye cask strength single barrel, the value is exceptional — comparable releases from other NDPs run $200+.
✓ Verdict: Best value in the NBC portfolio. If you like high-rye bourbon, this is the buy. 100 bottles still in stock on #2061.
Buy #2061 →
#5
NBC C-Series — C52 "Turkey" 9yr
C52 is the best barrel in the C-Series — a 9yr single barrel from Wild Turkey's Lawrenceburg distillery (DSP-KY-67), the Russell family's facility that has produced some of the most consistent high-rye Kentucky bourbon for 70 years. At 124.42°, it sits in the sweet spot: high enough to deliver real texture and depth, not so high that it requires significant dilution. Bold orange peel, vanilla, cracked black pepper, and the dark caramel that Wild Turkey's limestone bluff warehouse aging produces. At $119.99, it's 9yr Wild Turkey-sourced cask strength for the price of a standard bourbon.
✓ Verdict: Best C-Series pick. The "Turkey" nickname is earned — this tastes like what Wild Turkey 101 wishes it was.
Buy C52 →
#6
NBC C-Series — C13 8yr
C13 is the lowest-proof in the available C-Series, which makes it the most approachable — and at 118.04°, still firmly cask strength. The lower proof actually lets the wood and vanilla notes lead rather than the heat. If C52 is the spice-forward Wild Turkey pick, C13 is the sweeter, rounder one. Only 2 bottles remaining as of May 2026. This one is close to gone.
✓ Verdict: Best C-Series pick for people who want Wild Turkey character without maximum proof. Worth buying before it's gone.
Buy C13 →
#7
NBC Grateful Kelvin 8yr — #1931
#1931 is the entry point to the Grateful Kelvin series and the most available release — 18 bottles in stock. At 8yr and 121.28°, it's more restrained than the 10yr releases but shows the same defining character: the 36% rye mashbill and Kelvin cooperage combination that makes every Grateful Kelvin release instantly identifiable. For someone new to the series, #1931 is a lower-stakes introduction before committing to a 10yr barrel at $149.99.
✓ Verdict: Best Grateful Kelvin entry point. A good introduction to the series before stepping up to the 10yr barrels.
Buy #1931 →
#8
NBC Vault Series — 20yr Tennessee Bourbon #1439
The most accessible Vault Series release — at $279.99 versus $299.99 for the 21yr barrels, with 5 bottles still in stock. Twenty years in Tennessee oak produces the same profound age character as the 21yr barrels: dark dried fruit, old leather, toasted oak, and the slow-burn warmth that only extreme age produces. If the 21yr barrels are already gone when you're reading this, #1439 is the next best thing.
✓ Verdict: Best Vault Series buy if the 21yr barrels are sold out. Still a 20-year Tennessee bourbon at cask strength, which is extraordinary.
Buy #1439 →
How to Choose Your NBC Bottle
New to NBC: Start with The Compromise at $109.99. It's the most critically recognized release, the most balanced, and the lowest barrier to entry in the portfolio.
High-rye bourbon lover: Grateful Kelvin 10yr (#2061 or #2063). The 36% rye Kelvin combination is NBC's most distinctive flavor signature.
Kentucky bourbon traditionalist: C-Series, specifically C52 "Turkey." Wild Turkey-sourced cask strength at $119.99.
Collector or age statement hunter: Vault Series 21yr. One of the oldest Tennessee bourbons available for purchase anywhere, at any price.
NBC history and storytelling: Founders Fourteen. These are the barrels that started it all — and there aren't many left.
Taste Before You Buy
425 Church Street, Nashville · Walk-in flights from $35 · Every available NBC release in tasting rotation
Book a Tasting Shop Online